Madhu Sthapak
Acknowledgments
The highly enriching and beautiful journey of this field training was made possible by the support of several people to whom I extend my heartfelt gratitude. The first is Prof. Suneet Varma, our academic supervisor for this internship, who introduced to us the world of Indian Psychology and granted us the freedom to explore an unconventional arena for our internship. Then our field mentors, Ma Prachi, Ma Prem Devyani, Swami Amit Saraswati and Swami Atul Anand (Managing Trustee of Osho World Foundation) who considered our proposal and gave us the precious opportunity for learning at Osho Dham. They provided tremendous encouragement, support and guidance at every step for the entire period. All the meditation instructors, under whom we learnt various techniques, were equally supportive and ensured that we were deeply involved in the routine and practices, corrected our mistakes and resolved all our queries. The managing staff was warn, and welcoming; they were ever-ready to offer their assistance. Last but not the least, all the meditators and visitors who shared their experiences with us.
The kindness. generosity and open-hearted hospitality exhibited at Osho Dham not only exemplify a commitment to building a nurturing community but also serve as an example of how compassion can create a ripple effect, inspiring others to embrace similar values in their own lives. The atmosphere of love and acceptance at Osho Dham has greatly enriched our experience, leaving us with cherished memories and a renewed appreciation for the power of compassion.
Overview
At the beginning of the internship, the aim was to explore techniques and practices of Indian knowledge systems that can be used as alternatives or aids to traditional psychotherapy and medication. Moreover, we intended to discover the meeting points of psychology and spirituality in order to elucidate a potential synthesis between the two. Moreover, we sought an opportunity that could not only bring practical learning but also some form of inner transformation.
Among the various options we considered, Osho Dham (located in Pandwala Khurd, near Najafgarh) was the one that matched most closely with our requirements.
For the most holistic experience, and as there was facility for accommodation, we commuted to the site every Thursday evening and stayed there till Sunday night. The visit was made every weekend and the internship lasted from October 27, 2023 t0 November 26, 2023.
The internship consisted of four main components:
1. Experiential Learning
2. Observations
3. Interviewing visitors/meditators
4. A presentation of major insights and findings to our mentors and head of the organization
How the Healing Happens
1. A campus close to nature-
a. Roger Ulrich’s research on the Stress Reduction Theory has shown that exposure to natural environments can lead to physiological and psychological stress reduction. His landmark study demonstrated that hospital patients with a view of nature from tbeir windows experienced faster recovery and required fewer pain medications compared to those with views of built environments.
b. Ecotherapy, or nature therapy, is a concept that has been developed by various theorists, including Howard Clinebell and Theodore Roszak. Ecotherapy involves therapeutic practices in natural settings and is grounded in the belief that nature has healing properties for mental and emotional health. Richard Louv, known for his work on nature deficit disorder, emphasizes the importance of nature in fostering a sense of connection and well-being. His writings, such as “Last Child in the Woods,” highlight the psychological benefits of reconnecting with nature, especially for children.
c. The biophilia hypothesis by E.O. Wilson suggests that humans possess an innate tendency to seek connections with nature and other forms of life.
d. Stephen & Rachel Kaplan’s Attention Restoration Theory proposes that exposure to nature can improve our focus & alility to concentrate. They propose that natural environments provide a restorative effect by allowing individuals to engage in effortless attention, which contrasts with the directed attention required for many daily tasks.
2. A comfortable and uniform attire
a. Roy Baumeister, a social psychologist, bas researched decision fatigue, emphasizing that the more decisions individuals make, the lower the quality of subsequent decisions. Simplifying daily choices, such as clothing, aligns with this idea, reducing decision fatigue.
b. As per Identity Theory (Peter Burke and Jan E. Stets), wearing a uniform can contribute to a sense of shared identity and belonging. Social Identity Theory (Henri Tajfel and John Turner) explores how individuals categorize themselves and others into social groups. Uniform attire can contribute to a sense of group identity, fostering a perception of equality among group members.
c. Symbolic interactionism (George Herbert Mead) emphasizes the role of symbols and shared meanings in human interaction. Uniform attire with specific colours can be seen as a symbolic representation, communicating shared values within a community.
d. Social Comparison Theory (Leon Festinger) suggests that individuals determine their own social and personal worth based on how they stack up against others. Uniform attire reduces the likelihood of comparison based on clothing choices, fostering a more inclusive environmen
e. Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (Jon Kabat-Zinn): While not directly related to attire, Jon Kabat-Zinn’s work on mindfulness emphasizes being present in the moment. A uniform attire that minimizes distractions nlay contribute to individuals being more mindful of the present.
3. An atmosphere of warmth and unconditional positive regard
a. Central to humanistic psychology is Carl Rogers’s concept of unconditional positive regard. He emphasized the importance of creating an environment where individuals feel accepted and valued without judgment. In person–centered therapy, Rogers highlighted the therapeutic conditions of empathy, congruence, and unconditional positive regard. The latter involves providing nonjudgmental support and acceptance, creating a safe space for individuals to explore and express their thoughts and feelings.
b. Positive psychology focuses on human strengths, virtues, and factors that contribute to a fulfilling life. An atmosphere of warmth and unconditional positive regard aligns with the positive psychology approach, promoting well-being, positive emotions, and a supportive social environment.
c. Attachment theory by John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth emphasizes the importance of secure and supportive relationships in fostering emotional well-being. An atmosphere of warmth and positive regard can contribute to the development of secure attachment patterns, promoting a sense of safety and trust.
d. Albert Bandura’s Social cognitive theory acknowledges the impact of social environments on individual behaviour and learning. In an atmosphere of warmth and unconditional positive regard, individuals arc likely to experience positive social modeling. This modeling can include observing and learning from others’ positive behaviors, social interactions, and expressions of kindness. Bandura’s theory suggests that a positive and supportive social environment can contribute to the acquisition of positive behaviors and th development of prosocial skills through observational learning.
e. Transactional Analysis (TA) is a theory of personality and communication developed by Eric Berne. In TA, “strokes” refer to units of recognition or acknowledgment exchanged between individuals. Strokes can be positive (affirmative. validating) or negative (critical, disapproving). The concept of strokes emphasizes the importance of social interactions and their impact on an individual’s sense of self-worth and emotional well-being. An atmosphere characterized by warmth and unconditional positive regard provides individuals with positive strokes. Positive strokes include expressions of affirmation, recognition, and support. By fostering an environment where individuals receive positive strokes, Transactional Analysis suggests that people are more likely to develop a positive self-concept, experience emotional well-being, and engage in healthier interpersonal relationships.
b. Respect For the Will of the Person- ‘If you try forcing paradise on someone, the result will only be hell.’ Also, in such a case, the basic element of freedom is missing.
4. Homely vegetarian meals provided in fixed periods of the day
a. The field of ch.ronobiology emphasizes the role of circadian rhythms and biological clocks in regulating physiological processes, including appetite and digestion. Consistent meal schedules support the alignment of eating habits with the body’s natural circadian rhythms, potentially contributing to improved digestion and overall physical well-being.
b. Irregular eating patterns and reliance on junk food may contribute to increased stress. The lack of a structured meal routine and the potential negative impact of poor dietary choices can heighten stress levels, contrasting with the stress reduction potential of a regular, balanced meal schedule. A recent meta-analysis by Mazloomi et al. (2023) revealed that consumption of ultra-processed food is related to an enhanced depressive mental health status risk. Lane et al. (2022) also found that greater ultra-processed food consumption was cross-sectionally associated with increased odds of depressive and anxiety symptoms
c. Skinner’s operant conditioning theory highlights the role of reinforcement in shaping behavior. Consistent meal provision reinforces the behavior of anticipating and participating in meals at specific times, contributing to a predictable routine and potentially enhancing overall well-being.
d. The enjoyment of tasty meals can have emotional benefits, serving as a source of comfort and contributing to positive emotional states. Regularly receiving food from a specific place or person can create an emotional attachment, as the act of providing sustenance is a fundamental caregiving behavior.
Several visitors, especially females who generally bear full responsibility of taking care of their families, reported that it is a great respite not having to worry all the time about what to cook. More importantly, they mentioned, they felt ‘cared for‘.
5. Physical Activitv
While there are no exclusive exercise routines in the ashram, several meditation practices such as Kundalini and Dynamic (which are carried out every day without exception) as well as Nataraj Meditation, Kirtan, etc. enable vigorous free-flowing movement of the body. A report by the World Health Organization (2019), titled “Motion for you Mind” posited that physical activity is an effective strategy for promoting mental health and well-being and contribute to the treatment of mental health conditions. Some minutes from the report are:
a. Regular physical activity is a protective factor against depressive symptoms across all age groups, reducing the risk of depression by up to 45%, with just 60 minutes of weekly activity preventing 12% of new depression cases. Physical activity is comparably effective to cognitive-behavioral therapy or antidepressant medication for mild depressive symptoms and offers benefits even for severe, treatment-resistant depression. Its positive impact spans various life stages and settings, including children, adolescents, adults. postnatal periods, and late life, with observed effects in community settings.
b. Structured exercise interventions show promise in enhancing clinical, social, and cognitive aspects for children at risk of schizophrenia. Early lifestyle modifications are crucial due to high risks of obesity and non-communicable diseases in first-episode patients. Increased physical activity can improve symptoms and quality of life in schizophrenia, particularly reducing negative symptoms like apathy and flattened affect, which are not effectively addressed by antipsychotic medications.
Exercise also helps manage complications of antipsychotic medication, such as weight gain and cardio-metabolic dysfunction.
c. Physical activity serves as a protective factor against cognitive decline and neurodegenerative diseases, potentially lowering dementia risk by up to 10%. A 25% reduction in physical inactivity globally could prevent a million cases of Alzheimer’s disease. Regular physical activity not only diminishes cognitive decline but also enhances mobility and balance. The maintenance of muscle strength, healthy bones, and joints through physical activity reduces the risk of falls, benefiting individuals with dementia by promoting independent living and subsequently alleviating the caregiving burden.
d. A meta-analysis by Koch et a (2019) revealed that Dance Movement Therapy decreases depression and anxiety and increases quality of life and interpersonal and cognitive skills, whereas dance interventions increase (psycho-)molor skills.
Follow-up data showed that 22 weeks after the intervention, most effects remained stable or slightly increased.
6. Music
a. Instrumental music, especially when composed with soothing tones and rhythms, has the potential lo induce relaxation and reduce stress. This can be conducive to creating a peaceful and calming atmosphere within the ashram, supporting the meditative practices.
b. Emotional Resonance- Instrumental music has the ability to evoke emotions without the influence of lyrics. Depending on the composition. it can evoke feelings of tranquility, joy, introspection, or other emotional states, contributing to the overall ambiance of the ashram.
c. Facilitation of Movement and Dance- The music serves as a catalyst for physical expression.
d. The rhythmic and melodic elements of instrumental music can facilitate a connection between the mind and body. This integration is often emphasized in meditation practices, contributing to a holistic experience.
e. Depending on the nature of the music and the meditation techniques employed, instrumental music may contribute to inducing altered states of consciousness. This can include experiences of deep relaxation, heightened awareness, or a sense of transcendence.
f. In certain meditation practices that involve dynamic movement or expression, the instrumental music can serve as a medium for catharsis and emotional release. Participants may use the music to express and release stored emotions.
7. The Guru-Shishya relationship:
a. Like in the humanistic school of thought, the emphasis is on the power and capabilities of the individual, and how the person alone will be responsible for his actions, growth or otherwise.
b. TRUST- Bhakt/Faith is a highly important element in the therapeutic relationship.
c. The element of devotion to the guru can be helpful in that it can be extended to devotion for learning, with the guru serving as a role mode
d. Consistent with attachment theory, the relationship serves as a close, secure, emotionally-supponivc. and enduring connection. The uncertainty and transience in the modern world have us looking for something that will always stay.
8. The presence of a community, doing the meditations in a group
a. Group meditation provides a structured and supportive social setting. Engaging in a shared activity with others can alleviate feelings of isolation and contribute to a sense of community, potentially reducing loneliness. Saadati et al. (2014) stated that group therapy provides the opportunity to establish social relationships and reduce feelings of loneliness for individual that conttibute to the promotion of mental health in members.
b. Mirror neurons play a role in empathy and the imitation of behaviors. Meditating in a group setting involves a form of emotional contagion, where individuals mirror and synchronize their emotional states.
c. Durkheim introduced the concept of collective effervescence, describing the heightened emotional and social energy experienced in group rituals. Group meditation induces a collective state of positive energy and shared consciousness. Social facilitation suggests that the presence of others can enhance individual performance. In the context of meditation, being part of a group may lead to synchronized behavior and enhanced concentration and the depth of meditative states.
d. A recent study by Engert et a (2023), in the context of societal benefits of meditation argued that meditation-induced changes spread through the social networks of meditation practitioners. Such spreading may happen by positively influencing others through prosocial actions, improved cognitive functioning, and increased positive affect. Positive affective states and their underlying physiological correlates may also be shared in the literal sense.
e. Contagion theory manifests through the collective practice of meditation, creating an atmosphere where emotional states and behaviors quickly spread among participants. Moreover, dcindividuation emerges, leading individuals to lose their personal identity momentarily and let go of their narrow sense of self to be a part of the greater truth. There are sone potential downsides of these factors.
From the outside the environment and culture of the place seems very group-oriented and collectivistic. But the goal is, in fact, the development of a truly individualistic perspective. The purpose of all spirituality is not the abandonment of the self, but of all that we have been wrongly conditioned to associate with ‘self’.
Groupthink and Polarization– It was observed that a few people who were new to the ideas and practices of Osho and some of even those who had been meditating since several years had a vague and incomplete understanding which they openly discussed and even preached. While this is not a problem in itself, the person who spends a limited time at the place might be led to believe that Osho promotes superstitious beliefs the abandonment ofresponsibility (Both of which are found to be comforting by people who are not willing to invest the time and energy required to get to the depth of matters). While in fact, Osho is leading of not only freedom but also courage. His intent was the reconciliation of rationality and devotion, but devotion seems to dominate.
Osho in his discourses has repeatedly mentioned the importance of a critical stance.
“कुछ भी केवल मानना नहीं है , जानना है ”
(Nothing has to be just believed, it has to be known.)
Even while referring to Gautam Buddha, whom he highly respected and often talked about his teachings, Osho mentions that- ‘I am not going to be his voice, I am going to remain my voice… I will be even harder on Buddha, so that only the most essential and purest part of him reaches to humanity in the future.
The more scared someone is, the better follower they would become.
In Sufism, Haqiqah is the direct experience of mystical states, direct experience of God’s presence within. Without this experience, seekers blindly follow those who know- those who have attained the station of Haqiqah.
“It is easy to be faithful without any doubt and to be doubtful without any faith. How to create the contradictory polarities simultaneously, I am interested in this.”
– Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam
In the interaction with several regular meditators, one of the common theme that emerged from their responses was that understanding the logic of things is important. For instance, if one is practicing a technique without understanding the underlying reasons and objective of it, it does not tum out to be very helpful. Moreover, they recognized that meditation is NOT the one-stop solution for all problems. Some deep-seated traumas may require conventional psychotherapy and more importantly, the feeling of being uniquely listened to and understood by another human being. One participant mentioned that in some cases, medicine is a pre-requisite for getting a person’s mind to a manageable level, only after which the processes of meditation would become relevant.
Inner harmony is created by putting things in their right place which would involve at certain points, reconciliation of opposites. The process generally begins with some form of incongruence which people try avoiding as it may induce a state of existential anxiety. Extremities lead to the creation of the corresponding and often undesirable polar opposites. Moderation is the key. This also includes moderation of moderation. It connects with the concept of Buddhism’s “middle way”.
Another misconception that sometimes follows from the bhakti path is that God or Osho himself is a supreme being out there which is separate from the individual.
According to Osho, meditation means tuning and opening of the mind toward oneness. This can only happen when the meditation goes beyond you. It cannot happen if you are the controller because you are the disease. You will begin the meditation, but you will not end it. (Here, ‘you‘ refers to the narrow sense of self we live with).
If you try to surrender to someone, the other is there. So, the path or devotion cannot lead to the transcendental. It is just a question of surrendering the self- not at someone’s feet, just surrendering yourself…the self goes on creating deceptions and the greatest deception is that of ‘devotee’ and ‘God’.
A relationship is conditional, while oneness is non-conditional. A relationship is ever-changing nd stands the danger or being broken. This in turn leads to a cycle of fear and clinging.
The more you become obsessed with something, the farther you move away from it. Even in the spiritual quest, the error committed by most people is that they keep looking for the divine when it is actually right in front of you, right within you. All around you.
Moksha is not freedom ofthe self. It is freedom from the self.
Discourses
The presentation of audio and video discourses of Osho are an integral part of the place. Many of those are available in the form of books at the Dham’s library. When listened to carefully, they can have substantial therapeutic value and several parallels can be drawn with practices of mainstream psychology:
Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy (CBT): The discourses often tap on cognitive aspects, presenting ideas and perspectives that can influence thought patterns. Listening to discourses might be comparable to aspects of cognitive restructuring found in CBT, where individuals work to identify and change unhelpful thought patterns.
Psychoeducation: Discourses involve the transmission of knowledge and insights about the workings of the body and mind. This aligns with psychoeducation, a therapeutic approach that focuses on providing individuals with information and skills to better understand and manage their mental health.
Existential Therapy: Several discourses touch on existential themes, addressing questions about existence, meaning, and purpose. Listening to such discourses might parallel the exploration of existential concerns in existential therapy.
Humanistic Psychology: Osho’s focus on personal growth, self-expression, and individual potential resonates with humanistic psychology, particularly the ideas of self-actualization and the importance of personal responsibility.
In addition, the pace and intonation of the voice is such that it easily captures and sustains the attention of the listener while also having a calming effect on the mind.
The Meditations
One of the greatest things about this place is that it does not follow a one-size-fits-all approach. There is a vast range of techniques to explore. There were several practices we routinely engaged in (e.g. Kundalini, Nataraj, Nadabrahma meditation), each having a unique and profound impact. In the following pages, two of the techniques will be described in detail.
The first is Osho’s most well-kmown technique- Dynamic meditation. As the method and the underlying purpose of it is precisely elaborated in the book ‘Meditation: The First and the Last Freedom’, direct excerpts from it have been given in the report. The second is Laughter Meditation, for which an experiential account along with scientific research parallels have been discussed.
Dynamic Meditation
“…polarity is very meaningful for meditation because mind is logical and life is dialectical – it zigzags in opposites while mind denies the opposite…. The opposite is not to be left aside –
it has to be used. Left aside, it will always be a burden on you. Left aside, it will hang with vou…
Effortlessness means not doing anything, inactivity — akarma. Effort means doing much, activity karma. Both have to be there.
… Dynamic meditation is a contradiction. Dynamic means effort, much effort, absolute effort. And meditation means silence, no effort, no activity. You can call it a dialectical meditation.”
Instructions for Dynamic Meditation
1. First stage: 10 minutes
Breathing rapidly in and out through the nose, let breathing be intense and chaotic. The breath should move deeply into the lungs. Be as fast as you can in your breathing, making sure breathing stays deep. Do this as totally as you possibly can; without tightening up your body, make sure neck and shoulders stay relaxed. Continue until you literally become the breathing, allowing breath to be chaotic (that means not in a steady, predictable way). Once your energy is moving, it will begin to move your body. Allow these body movements to be there, use them to help you build up even more energy. Moving your arms and body in a natural way will help your energy to rise. Feel your energy building up; don’t let go during the first stage and never slow down.
2. Second stage: 10 minutes
Follow your body. Give your body freedom to express whatever is there …. EXPLODE! …. Let your body take over. Let go of everything that needs to be thrown out. Go totally mad…. Sing, screamy laugh, shout, cry, jump, shake, dance, kick, and throw yourself around. Hold nothing back, keep your whole body moving. A little acting often helps to get you started. Never allow your mind lo interfere with what is happening. Remember to be total with your body.
3. Third stage: 10 minutes
Leaving your shoulders and neck relaxed, raise both arms as high as you can without locking the elbows. With raised arms, jump up and down shouting the mantra HOO.’…HOO!…HOO! as deeply as possible, coming from the bottom of your belly. Each time you land on the flats of your feet (making sure heels touch the ground). Give all you have, exhaust yourself completely.
4. Fourth stage: 15 minutes
STOP! Freeze where you are in whatever position you find yourself.
Don ‘t arrange the body in any way. A cough, a movement, anything will dissipate the energy flow and tbe effort will be lost. Be a witness to everything. that is happening to you.
5. Fifth stage: 15 minutes
Celebrate!… with music and dance express whatsoever is there. Carry your aliveness with you throughout the day.
The Purpose
Dynamic Meditation begins with breathing, because breathing has deep roots in the being. If you observe your breathing carefully, you will see that when you are angry you have a particular rhythm of breathing. W hen you are in love, a totally different rhythm comes to you. W hen you arc relaxed you breathe differently; when you are tense you breathe differently. You cannot breathe the way you do when you are relaxed and be angry at the same time. It is impossible. W hen you are sexually aroused, your breathing changes. If you do not allow the breathing to change, your sexual arousal will drop automatically. This means that breathing is deeply related to your mental state. If you change your breathing, you can change the state of your mind. Or, if you change the state of your mind, breathing will change.
The chaotic breathing is to destroy all your past patterns. What you have made out of yourself, this chaotic breathing is to destroy. Chaotic breathing creates a chaos within you because unless a chaos is created, you cannot release your repressed emotions. And those emotions have now moved into the body. You are not body and mind; you are body/mind, psycho/somatic. You are both together. So whatever is done with your body reaches to the mind and whatever is done with the mind reaches to the body.
Deep, fast breathing gives you more oxygen. The more oxygen in the body, the more alive you become, the more animal-like. Animals are alive and man is half-dead, half-alive. You have to be made into an animal again. Only then can something higher develop in you. If you are only half-alive, nothing can be done with you. So this chaotic breathing will make you like an animal: alive, vibrating, vital – with more oxygen in your blood, more energy in your cells. Your body cells will become more alive. This oxygenation helps to create body electricity – or, you can call it bio-energy. When there is electricity in the body you can move deep within, beyond yourself. The electricity will work within you. The body has its own electrical sources. If you hammer them with more breathing and more oxygen, they begin to flow. The more alive you become, the more energy flows in your system and the less you will feel yourself physically. You will feel more like energy and less like matter.
The second step of Dynamic Meditation is a catharsis. I tell you to be consciously insane. Whatever comes to your mind -whatever – allow it to express itself; cooperate with it. No resistance; just a flow of emotions. If you want to scream, then scream. Cooperate with it. A deep scream, a total scream in which your whole being becomes involved, is deeply therapeutic. If the scream is total, your whole being will be in it.
So, for the next ten minutes (this second step is also for ten minutes) allow yourself expression through crying, dancing, screaming, weeping, jumping, laughing – ‘freaking out’ as they say. Within a few days, you will come to feel what it is. In the beginning it may be forced, an effort, or it may even be just acting. We have become so false that nothing real or authentic can be done by us. We have not laughed, we have not cried, we have not screamed authentically. Everything is just a fa~ade – a mask. So when you begin to do this technique- in the beginning- it may be forced. Soon you will touch those sources where you have repressed many things. You will touch those sources, and once they are released, you will feel unburdened. A new life will come to you; a new birth will take place.
With this second step – when things are thrown out – you become vacant.
And this is what is meant by emptiness: to be empty of all repressions. In this emptiness something can be done. Transformation can happen; meditation can happen.
Then in the third step I use the sound ‘hoo‘. Many sounds have been used in the past. Each sound has something specific to do. For example, Hindus have been using the sound ‘Om’. I won’t suggest Om as it strikes at the heart center, but man is no longer centered in the heart. Om is striking at a door where no one is home. Sufis have used hoo, and if you say boo loudly, it goes deep to the sex center. So this sound is used just as a hammering within. When you have become empty and vacant, this sound can move within you.
The movement of the sound is possible only when you are empty. lf you are filled with repressions, nothing will happen. And sometimes it is even dangerous to use any mantra or sound when you are filled with repressions.
Each layer of repression will change the path of the sound and the ultimate result may be something of which you never dreamed, never expected, never wished. You need a vacant mind; only then can a mantra be used.
These first three steps are cathartic. They arc not meditation, but just preparation for it. They are a ‘getting ready’ to take the jump, not the jump itself. The fourth step is the jump. In the fourth step I tell you to stop! When I say “Stop!” stop completely. Don’t do anything at all because anything you do can become a diversion and you will miss the point.
Now your whole body will become so silent- as if it has disappeared. You will not be able to feel it. You have become bodiless. And when you are silent, the whole existence is silent because the existence is nothing but a mirror. It reflects you. In thousands and thousands of mirrors, it rellects you. When you are silent. the whole existence has become silent.
In your silence I will tell you to just be a witness – a constant alertness: not doing anything, but just remaining a witness, just remaining with yourself; not doing anything – no movement, no desire, no becoming – but just remaining then and there, silently witnessing what is happenin g. That is meditation. In that meditation something happens that is beyond words. And once it happens you will never be the same again; it is impossible. It is a growth; it is not simply an experience.
In all active meditations, there was a shift from DOING to HAPPENING. It is similar to how the best poetry HAPPENS. The best art HAPPENS,
What is important is being aware, being a witness.
Laughter Meditation
OSHO-“Laughter brings some energy from your inner source to your surface … When you really laugh, for those few moments you are in a deep meditative state- all boundaries, all divisions are lost. It is impossible to laugh and think together. Laughter can be a beautiful introduction to a non-thinking state … ”
Laughter is a very special phenomenon. Unfortunately, its (psycho)therapeutic value is underestimated and its transforming force is not used to its full extent. (Sutorius, 1995)
In a review paper about the therapeutic benefits of laughter in mental health, Yim (2016) stated that decreasing stress-making hormones found in the blood, laughter can mitigate the effects of stress. Laughter decreases serum levels of cortisol, epinephrine, growth hormone, and 3,4-dihydrophenylacetic acid (a major dopamine catabolitc). indicating a reversal of the stress response. Depression is a disease, where neurotransmitters in the brain, such as norepinephrine, dopamine, and serotonin, are reduced, and there is something wrong in the mood control circuit of the brain. Laughter can alter dopamine and serotonin activity. Furthermore, endorphins secreted by laughter can help when people are uncomfortable or in a depressed mood. Laughter therapy is a non-invasive and non-pharmacological alternative treatment for stress and depression, representative cases that have a negative influence on mental health. In conclusion, laughter therapy is effective and scientifically supported as a single or adjuvant therapy.
In several studies, Laughter has shown physiological, psychological, social, spiritual, and quality-of-life benefits. Adverse effects are very limited, and laughter is practically lacking in contraindications. Therapeutic efficacy oflaughter is mainly derived from spontaneous laughter (triggered by external stimuli or positive emotions) and self-induced laughter (triggered by oneself at will), both occurring with or without humour. The brain is not able to distinguish between these types; therefore, it is assumed that similar benefits may be achieved with one or the other.
In one study, participants were injected with a radioactive compound that adheres to opioid receptors in the brain. Using positron emission tomography (PET) imaging, the researchers were then able to monitor the release of endorphins and other peptides that bind to opioid rectors.
Participants underwent PET scans twice. The first scan was conducted after each participant spent 30 minutes alone in a room. and once after they spent 30 minutes watching laughter-inducing video clips of their close friends.
The researchers found that the social laughter condition led to a significant increase in endorphin release in the thalamus. caudate nucleus, and anterior insula regions of the brain. These are brain regions that play a role in arousal and emotional awareness.
AdditionaJiy, the team found that participants with a greater number of opioid receptors in the cingulate and orbitofrontal cortices of the brain were more likely to laugh in response to their friends’ video clips. The cingulatc cortex is involved in the processing and formation of emotions, while the orbitofrontal cortex is involved in a number of emotion-related processes.
“The pleasurable and calming effects of the endorphin release might signal safety and promote feelings of togetherness. the researchers suggested.
Because social laughter leads to similar chemical response in the brain, this allows significant expansion of human social networks: laughter is highly contagious, and the endorphin response may thus easily spread through large groups that laugh together.”
As the philosopher Bertrand Russell once said: “Laughter is the most inexpensive and most effective wonder drug. Laughter is a universal medicine.” Over the years, researchers have pitted its abilities against a range of medical conditions.
Personal Experience
The instruction during the session was to just let go and laugh without verbalizing. Beginning with a fake laughter, there was a gradual proceeding towards uninhibited deep laughter originating from the belly. It was as if it had been wanting to emerge since a long time. As laughter is clearly contagious, watching each other laugh, there were soon roars of laughter echoing in the room. Lt was occurring to me how silly life really is and what a huge issue we have created out of it all. And that made me laugh even more. Followed by this were phases when Twas laughing but not because of any reason. Those arc the moments of meditation – you become the laughter, letting go of everything else.
Music began and there was a cue to start dancing. This dance was very special. People were feeling really connected to each other, joyfully sharing a few steps with those around them. Shyness had taken a backseat like it never did before. In daily life, there is so much of categorization we engage in- judging ourselves and those around us. And even while we may do so mainly for pragmatic reasons, it creates in our being a divide- a sense of separateness that leads to misery. In that case- a few moments of pure and unconditional connection can work wonders for liberating our true nature and overcoming our constricted sense of self. “Unn logon mein mai khud ko dekh pa rahi thi. Hum ek hi toh hai”
I came out of the room feeling cleansed, lighter and blissful. Energetic on the outside and silent and still on the inside. It is remarkable thar merely five hours ago, during dynamic meditation I had cried with great intensity and on the very same day, Twas laughing with such intensity. As a person who gets readily immersed in emotions, it sometimes becomes difficult to realize their transience and recognize the illusion of the identification of one’s thoughts and emotions with one’s whole being.
Major insights from the Internship
Meditation for Broadening the Horizons of Life
As per our experience and observations, the essence of meditation lies in awareness. We are in a state of perpetual inner chatter or outward talking. There is so much of DOING and not enough BEING. While work and language are needed, they are not needed all the time. Once started, we find it strikingly difficult to tum our brain machines off. “There must be moments when you are existential and not linguistic. Language is bound to be repetitive. Existence is never repetitive. You have killed the new through the old word.” That, in turn, leads to boredom and being unconscious even in the waking state. Meditation helps to bring forth the essential in you; the essential that our species has long-forgotten, the essential that we do not have the time to look at.
“We train a child to focus his mind, to concentrate. because without concentration he will not be able to cope with life. Life requires it; the mind must be able to concentrate. But the moment the mind becomes able lo concentrate, it becomes less aware. Awareness means a mind that is conscious but not focused. Awareness is a consciousness of al I that is happening. Concentration is a choice. It excludes all except its object of concentration; it is a narrowing. If you arc walking on the street, you will have to narrow your consciousness in order to walk. You cannot ordinarily be aware of all that is happening because if you are aware of everything that is happening you will become unfocused. So concentration is a need. Concentration of the mind is a need in order to live–to survive and exist. That is why every culture, in its own way, tries to narrow the mind of the child.
Children, as they are. are never focused; their consciousness is open from all sides. Everything is coming in, nothing is being excluded. The child is open to every sensation. every sensation is included in his consciousness. And so much is coming in! That is why he is so wavering, so unstable. A child’s unconditioned mind is a flux–a flux of sensations–but he will not be able to survive with this type of mind. He must learn how to narrow his mind, to concentrate. The moment you narrow the mind you become particularly conscious of one thing and simultaneously unconscious of so many other things. The more narrowed the mind is, the more successful it will be. You will become a specialist, you will become an expert, but the whole thing will consist of knowing more and more about less and less.
The narrowing is an existential necessity; no one is responsible for it. As life exists, it is needed, but it is not enough. It is utilitarian, but just to survive is not enough; just to be utilitarian is not enough. So, when you become utilitarian and the consciousness is narrowed, you deny your mind much of which it was capable. You are not using the total mind, you are using a very small part of it.”
-Meditation: The Art of Celebration (Osho, 1970)
The education system is designed to reward our knowledge, not our curiosity … our fullness not our receptivity. Self-promotion has inflated our egos. And that limits us. Growth comes through insecurity. This fighting into and living in the unknown is the real renunciation that is required. We can be open only when we are humble in our ignorance. The moment of emptiness, when memory ceases is ‘dhyana’. This is the starting point of true wisdom.
People are caught up in all forms of compulsions, addictions and unhelpful habits because
i. They have no adequate knowledge related to the underlying mechanisms of those
ii. In case they do (as in case of psychologists, for example), they arc not A WAKE
Despite ‘knowing’ everything, we keep inflicting harm on ourselves and others. After getting into a state of total awareness, there are still urges to fall back into the same pattern. However, they arc just like thoughts- which were earlier so loud and overpowering but have now become distant whispers.
So, knowledge by itself is not the answer. One needs to become conscious.
‘No special living is required, but the moment you become aware, your living changes, your life will change. And these changes will come to you, they will not be practiced.’
Suppression of Emotions
In the orthodox part of our culture, an emphasis on traditional values, collectivism, and gender roles has contributed to a norm of emotional restraint. The promotion of dignity, self-discipline, and composure often leads individuals to prioritize emotional control, particularly in the face of challenges. Expressing strong emotions, especially negative ones, may be perceived as disruptive or socially inappropriate, and there is a prevailing expectation to uphold a facade of emotional well-being.
The fast-paced nature of contemporary life, coupled with the influence of social media, can contribute to a culture that values external success and achievements over authentic emotional expression. Moreover, the fear ofjudgment, societal stigma surrounding mental health discussions, and a constant influx of information may lead individuals to suppress or downplay their emotions.
The extent and intensity of venting and catharsis by the visitors of Osho Dham gave a deep insight into the general human condition. As Freud suggested correctly, ‘anything suppressed will comeforth later, in uglierforms‘. Persistent suppression of emotions can contribute to psychological distress, leading to increased levels of anxiety, stress, and even symptoms of depression. Unexpressed emotions may build up, creating an emotional burden that weighs heavily on an individual’s merital health. Moreover, repressing emotions diminishes self-awareness, as individuals may become disconnected from their authentic feelings and needs. At the interpersonal level, inability to convey one’s emotional state can lead to misunderstandings, misinterpretations. and a lack of emotional intimacy, hindering meaningful exchanges.
Osho’s method of catharsis provides a structured and supportive framework for individuals to release pent-up emotions, fostering mental clarity, emotional well-being, and self-discovery. However, the release of emotions can sometimes come along with increased distress and confusion, in which case guidance from a close instructor or support from a psychologist may be required.
Fragmentation of the human being
It is no measure ofhealth to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society.
– J. Krishnamurti
Gestalt psychology and therapy emphasizes the importance of understanding the whole person and the integration of different aspects of one’s experience. Following are some related excerpts from Osho’s book ‘The Psychology of the Esoteric’.
“. every period, every nation, every pan of the world, every culture and society has always chosen apart and emphasized the part, and created a personality around it. The personality has been poor, lacking much. Neither the East has been rich spiritually nor the West.
Richness comes through the opposite. An inner dialogue, an inner dialectic. So to me, neither the East is worth choosing nor the West. To me, a different mind, an altogether different quality of mind, has to be chosen – and that quality means one has to be ease with oneself, without choosing.
For example, a tree grows: we can choose; we can cut down all the branches and we can allow the tree to grow only in one direction, one branch growing. It will be a poor tree, very poor and very ugly, and ultimately the tree is bound to be in very deep difficulty because this branch cannot grow. It can grow only in a deep relationship with other branches. A tree, to be really rich, strong and multidimensional, must grow in all the directions, opposite directions.
To me, the human spirit must grow like a tree, in all directions. But up until now this has not been the case. Up until now we have tried a specialization with the human mind also- one should grow in one specific direction. Then something ugly happens. One grows in a specific direction, but then he lacks everything. He becomes one branch. not a tree. And this branch is bound to be poor.
Not only have we been cutting the branches of the mind, we have been cutting the roots. We allow only one root and one branch, so a very starved human has come up all over the world. In the East, in the West. everywhere- very starved. And the East is always attracted toward the West and the West is attracted to the East, because I am attracted to something which I lack, you are attracted to something which you lack. If you lack religion, whenever you feel starved you are attracted to the East. When the East begins to feel poor, poverty-stricken, diseased, ill, the East begins to be attracted towards the West, because of science, technology, medicine, affluence, everything.
But we can change positions and the disease remains the same. So, it is now a question of changing the whole perspective. It is not a question of changing the East to the West. Now it is a question of changing the whole past into a new future. The whole past has been a fragmentary choice of human possibilities. We have never accepted the whole being.
The problem is colossal, arduous, because this fragmentation has become so deep-rooted. l cannot accept my anger, I cannot accept my sex, I cannot accept my body, I cannot accept myself in my totality. Somewhere something has to be denied and thrown away. Something is evil, something is bad, something is a sin. So I go on cutting branches and ultimately I am not a tree, not an alive thing, just dead, because this fear of growing into branches which I have denied … they can again come up. So I become fearful, everywhere suppressed and fearful. Then, a disease sets in: a sadness, a death.”
In fact, there is no boundary between conscious and unconscious. These are not two minds. “Conscious mind“ means that part ofthe mind that has been used in the narrowing process. “Unconscious mird“ means that portion that has been neglected, ignored, closed. This creates a division, a split. The greater portion ofyour mind becomes alien to you. You become alienatedfromyour own self; you become a stranger to your own totality.‘
Becoming vs. Being
‘The less one is a being inwardly, the more he/she must substitute oneselfoutwardly. That is why everyone is in fear, constantfear ofothers, because they are contributors ofyour self... We are afraid ofbeing empty so we cling to outside accumulation.‘ –Osho
Alfred Adler’s Individual Psychology posits that humans are primarily motivated by social connectedness and a striving for superiority or success. He believed that feelings of inferiority drive individuals to achieve personal goals. The relentless pursuit of superiority to overcome feelings of inadequacy often leads to burnout, stress, and strained relationships. In a competitive environment, individuals driven by an inferiority complex might engage in unhealthy competition, creating a culture of comparison and hindering collaborative efforts. Moreover, the dependency on external validation in the age of social media may amplify these challenges, as individuals seek constant affirmation from virtual sources.
In one of his discourses, Osho said rightly- “You have never been accepted by your parents, teachers, neighbours, society as you arc. Everybody was trying to improve upon you. To make you better. Constant conditioning in you has created in you the idea that, “I am not enough as I am … Something is missing and I have to be somewhere else not here. This is not the place I am supposed to be, but somewhere higher, more dominant, more respected, more well-known.”
At Osho Dham, individuals learn to embrace the present moment, cultivate inner awareness, and experience a state or authentic being. This shift involves letting go of the ego-driven desires for constant achievement and recognition, and instead, immersing oneself in the richness of the present. While some people may mistakenly believe that Osho is simply negating the importance of striving for growth and betterment, he is actually illuminating the path of truly boundless growth and flourishment:
1. True growth begins with self-acceptance, allowing individuals to acknowledge their strengths and imperfections without judgment. This acceptance serves as a foundation for authentic personal development
2. Authenticity fosters a sense of integrity and inner harmony. Individuals can align their actions with their true values, fostering personal growth that is aligned with their authentic self.
3. By cultivating mindfulness, individuals develop a heightened awareness of their thoughts, emotions, and actions. This awareness facilitates conscious decision-making and a more profound understanding of the self.
4. In moments of inner silence, individuals can access their innate wisdom. This inner wisdom guides decision-making, problem-solving, and the pursuit of personal goals.
5. True growth involves enjoying the journey rather than being solely focused on reaching an idealized destination. This approach fosters a positive and fulfilling attitude toward personal development.
6. Letting go of comparisons allows individuals to appreciate their unique journey. True growth is about self-discovery and self-improvement rather than conforming to external standards.
7. Finally, for the spiritually inclined, growth is characterized by a deeper connection with oneself and the universe, unfolds trough being present, cultivating gratitude, and experiencing a sense of interconnectedness.
Celebrate Life, Celebrate Existence
Generally, the higher we reach in life, the more distant we become from our inner child and get absorbed by a ‘cult of seriousness’ to the detriment of lightheartedness, joy, and playfulness. In a broader sense, the “cult of seriousness” might be associated with a societal or organizational emphasis on rigid formality, strict adherence to rules, and a lack of tolerance for humor or spontaneity.
Following are some relevant quotes from Osho –
“To me, life in its totality is good. And when you understand life in its totality, only then can you celebrate; otherwise not. Celebration means: whatsoever happens is irrelevant –I celebrate. Celebration is not conditional on certain things: ‘When Tam happy then Twill celebrate,’or, ‘When I am unhappy, I will not celebrate.’ No. Celebration is unconditional; I celebrate life. It brings unhappiness – good, I celebrate it. It brings happiness good, I celebrate it. Celebration is my attitude, unconditional to what life brings.
“But a problem arises because whenever I use words, those words have connotations in your mind. When I say ‘Celebrate’, you think one bas to be happy. How can one celebrate when one is sad? I am not saying that one has to be happy to celebrate. Celebration is gratefulness for whatsoever life gives to you. Whatsoever existence gives to you. celebration is a gratitude: it is a gratefulness.”
“Whatsoever you can be you arc. There is no goal. And we arc not going anywhere. We arc simply celebrating here. Existence is not a journey, it is a celebration. Think of it as a celebration, as a delight, as a joy! Don’t turn it into a suffering, don’t turn it into a duty, a work. Let it be play.”
The serious person becomes handicapped, he creates barriers. He cannot dance, he cannot sing, he cannot celebrate. The very dimension of celebration disappears from his life. He becomes desert-like. And if you are a desert, you can go on thinking and pretending that you are religious but you are not.’
“People who are not enjoying their lives in the present have lust for life in the future. Lust for life is always in the future. It is a postponement. They are saying, ‘We cannot enjoy today so we will enjoy tomorrow.’ They are saying, ‘Right this moment we cannot celebrate, so let there be a tomorrow so tbat we can celebrate.’ … Future arises out of your misery, not out of your celebration. A really celebrating person has no future; he lives this moment, he lives it totally. Out of that total living arises the next moment, but it is not out of any lust. Of course, when out of celebration the next moment arises, it has more capacity to bless you. When out of celebration the future arises, it goes on becoming more and more rich. And a moment comes when the moment is so total, so whole, that time completely disappears …. Time is a need of the miserable mind. Time is a creation of misery. If you are happy there is no time -• time disappears.”
“The workaholics have done immense harm to the world. And the greatest harm they have done is that they have deprived Ii fc of its moments of celebration and festivity. It is because of them that there is so little festivity in the world, and every day it is becoming more and more dull and dreary and miserable. …In fact, entertainment has taken the place of celebration in the present world. But entertainment is quite different from celebration; entertainment and celebration arc never the same. In celebration you arc a participant; in entertainment you are only a spectator. In entertainment you watch others playing for you. So while celebration is active, entertainment is passive. In celebration you dance, while in entertainment you watch someone dancing, for which you pay him… But there is a world of difference between dancing and watching a dance performed by a group of professionals who are paid for it. You work hard during the day, and when you are tired in the evening you go to a concert to watch others dancing. 1t is al I you can do, but it is not even an apology for celebration.”
It does not mean that there will be no work if we turn life into a celebration. It is not that the wind does not work; it is always moving, blowing. It’ is not that the stars are idle; they are constantly moving. It is not that flowers don’t do anything when they bloom; really, they do a lot. But for them, doing it is not that important; what is important is being.”
References
Engert, V., Klimecki, 0. M., Kanske, P., & Mindful Universities Research Group (2023).
Spreading positive change: Societal benefits of meditation. Frontiers in psychiatry, 14,
1038051. https://doi.org/l 0.3389/fpsyt.2023.1038051
Manninen, S., Tuominen, L., Dunbar, R. I., Karjalainen, T., Hirvonen, J., Arponen, E., Hari, R., J~~skel~inen, I. P., Sams, M., & Nummenmaa, L. (2017). Social laughter triggers endogenous opioid release in humans. Journal of Neuroscience, 37(25), 6125-6131. https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSC10688-16.2017
Mazloomi, S.N., Talebi, S., Mehrabani, S., Bagheri. R., Ghavami, A., Zarpoosh. M..
Mohammadi. H., Wong, A., Nordva!l, M., Kermani, M.A. H., & Moradi, S. (2023). The association of ultra-processed food consumption with adult mental health disorders: a systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis of 260,385 participants. Nutritional Neuroscience, 26( 10), 913-931. https://doi.org/10.1080/1028415X.2022.2110188
Osho, Swami Deva Wadud (Comp.), Ma Anand Svarup (Assist.), & Ma Yoga Ranjana (Ed.). (1996). Meditation: The First and Last Freedom. St. Martin’s Press.
Saadati, H., Shoaee, F., Pouryan, A., Alkasir, E., & Lashani, L. (2014). Effectiveness of Gestalt Group Therapy on Loneliness of Women Caregivers of Alzheimer Patients at Home. Iranian Rehabilitation Journal, 12022), 54.
Sutorius, D. ( 1995). The transforming force of laughter. with the focus on the laughing meditation .. 2601-3), 367-371. doi: 10.1016/0738-3991 (95)00760-w
Yim, J. (2016). Therapeutic Benefits of Laughter in Mental Health: A Theoretical Review.
The Tohoku Journal of Experimental Medicine. (3), 243-249.
https://doi.org IO. I 620/tjem.239.243
Appendix